Honest Selkie Review // Whimsical Plus Size Dresses
This content is reader-supported, which means if you click on some of our links we may earn a commission. Thank you for your continued support.
When it comes to dreamy, ethereal dresses, Selkie is a name that immediately comes to mind. Known for its whimsical designs, puff sleeves, and fairytale-inspired aesthetics, Selkie has become a go-to for anyone looking to feel like royalty. But how does Selkie fare when it comes to plus size fashion? As a plus size person who loves all things glamorous, I was eager to find out. In this Selkie review, I’ll share my honest thoughts, including fit, comfort, style, and whether these dresses are truly worth the investment. Plus, if you’re considering your first Selkie purchase, stick around for a Selkie discount code to save on your order.
The Magic of Selkie: What Makes It Special?
Selkie is a brand that thrives on nostalgia, femininity, and whimsy. Founded by Kimberley Gordon, the brand takes inspiration from childhood dreams, vintage aesthetics, and magical fairy tales. From voluminous puff dresses to romantic silk gowns, each piece feels like it was plucked from a storybook. But what sets Selkie apart isn’t just its designs — it’s their commitment to extended sizing. Selkie offers many of their styles in sizes XXS to 6X, making their enchanting pieces accessible to more bodies.
Honest Selkie Review: Fit and Sizing
As a plus size person, finding dresses that fit well can be a challenge. Selkie’s size range is impressive compared to many brands, but how does the fit actually feel? I ordered three different styles in a 5X, which corresponds to a size 26/28. Here’s what I discovered:
The Puff Dress
The Classic Puff Dress is arguably Selkie’s most iconic piece. With its voluminous skirt and puff sleeves, it promises a fairytale look. When I tried it on, I immediately understood the hype.
• Fit: True to size but snug in the bust. If you have a larger chest, consider sizing up.
• Comfort: The fabric is lightweight but not necessarily breathable.
• Style: The silhouette is stunning — twirl-worthy and perfect for photoshoots. Runs short so make sure to wear something underneath like Thigh Society Anti-chafing shorts.
The Puff Dress made me feel like a princess, but it’s definitely more of a statement piece than an everyday outfit.
The French Puff
The French Puff Dress offers a slightly more relaxed silhouette while maintaining the brand’s signature aesthetic.
• Fit: More forgiving than the Classic Puff, especially around the waist.
• Comfort: The soft organza feels luxurious.
• Style: Ideal for garden parties or whimsical outings.
I appreciated how this style flattered my plus size figure without overwhelming it. The sleeves have enough stretch to accommodate larger arms, which is often an issue with other brands.
The Day Dress
The Day Dress combines puff sleeves with a more casual design.
• Fit: Has a tighter under bust which is great for going bra free, I love to order down to a 4X to ensure a snug, yet comfortable, fit.
• Comfort: Extremely comfortable, with a more relaxed lining.
• Style: Great for casual whimsical looks.
This dress was perfect for a dreamy day out and felt less restrictive than the puff styles.
Material and Quality: What to Expect
Selkie dresses are primarily made from organza, which gives them their signature volume and lightweight feel. While the fabric is gorgeous, it can feel scratchy if you’re not used to it. I recommend wearing a slip underneath if you have sensory sensitivities. The stitching and construction are solid — I didn’t experience any fraying or loose seams. Also noteworthy is that organza is not stretchy. I typically order a 5X in any organza designs to ensure a comfortable fit.
One thing to note: these dresses are delicate. They’re designed for special occasions and photoshoots, not heavy wear. Proper care is essential. Always follow the garment care instructions to maintain the fabric’s integrity.
Honest Selkie Review: Accessibility in Plus Size Fashion
One of the most impressive aspects of Selkie is their inclusive size range. As a plus size person, it’s rare to find whimsical, high-fashion dresses available beyond a size 20. Selkie’s commitment to offering their pieces in sizes up to 6X is a breath of fresh air in the fashion world.
However, some styles are only available in straight sizes or take longer to restock in extended sizes. I hope Selkie continues to expand its offerings so more plus size individuals can experience the magic of their dresses.
Styling Tips for Plus Size Selkie Dresses
If you’re new to Selkie or looking for ways to make these statement dresses work for everyday wear, here are a few styling tips:
- Layer Smartly: Add a cropped cardigan or denim jacket to tone down the whimsical factor for casual outings.
- Choose the Right Undergarments: The puff dresses benefit from a good supportive bra, especially if you’re fuller-busted.
- Accessorize Minimally: Let the dress shine by keeping accessories simple — think pearl earrings or a dainty necklace.
- Comfort Shoes: Pair with ballet flats, sandals, or even sneakers for a comfortable, stylish look.
Price vs. Value: Is Selkie Worth It?
Selkie dresses are undoubtedly an investment. With most pieces ranging from $200 to $400, it’s essential to consider whether the value matches the price. Here’s my take:
• Unique Design: If you’re drawn to fairytale aesthetics, Selkie is unmatched.
• Inclusive Sizing: The availability of extended sizes makes the brand more accessible.
• Quality Construction: Despite the delicate material, the craftsmanship is impressive.
If you plan to wear your Selkie dress for photoshoots, events, or just as a fun addition to your wardrobe, the cost can be justified. If you’re unsure, start with one of their simpler styles to test the waters or wait for their surprise bags which are an amazing deal.
Selkie Discount Code: Save on Your Dream Dress
Selkie delivers on its promise of whimsical, enchanting dresses. From the fit to the style, each piece feels like stepping into a fairytale. While the organza material takes some getting used to, the overall effect is worth it. As a plus size person, I appreciate the effort Selkie puts into size inclusivity, even if there’s still room for improvement.
If you’ve been dreaming of twirling around in a puff dress or channeling your inner princess, Selkie is worth the investment. And don’t forget to use the Selkie discount code FlyForAGinger to save 10% on your magical new dress. It’s the perfect way to experience the magic of Selkie while saving a bit of money.
Final Thoughts on Selkie
I hope you enjoyed this honest Selkie review! If you are looking for more whimsical plus size fashion content please check out these other blogs posts:
Plus Size Selkie Inspired Dresses
Where to Find Plus Size Royalcore Clothes
Until next time,
XO Victoria
FlyForAGinger is a blog about plus size fashion, experiences with health issues like psoriasis and PCOS, and promotes body positivity with a focus on cultivating plus size community.
FlyForAGinger was created by Victoria Voos, the creator behind it all. Learn more about her HERE and see where she has been featured in other publications like The New York Times HERE.
